HGSU Bargaining Portal

Come here for all things bargaining! We’ve launched our live bargaining tracker below which tracks all contract articles proposed by HGSU and the University. After each bargaining session, we will update the tracker, send an email update to HGSU members, and provide a press release.

Next bargaining session: Thursday, May 1st – RSVP for live caucus room and post-bargaining debrief coming soon!

Questions? Want to contribute to bargaining? [email protected] or #ask-bargaining in Slack or announcements in WhatsApp

Bargaining Tracker

Bargaining Updates

TLDR: We brought article proposals on appointment letters, grievance & arbitration, and workspace/materials & remote work. Harvard passed us a proposal on intellectual property. Check out our new Bargaining Portal with all updates on bargaining! We will continue to push for transparent Zoom bargaining.

Despite proceeding without ground rules, we had a productive bargaining session with Harvard last Thursday, 4/10. HGSU brought a full bargaining team with our core bargaining committee and student workers from across the University – see next paragraph to get involved with our next bargaining session! We presented three article proposals: Articles 3 (Appointment Letter), 6 (Grievance and Arbitration), and 15 (Workspace, Remote Work, and Materials). Harvard’s Bargaining Team passed us a proposal on Article 9 (Intellectual Property, Scholarly, and Research Misconduct). Each team had the opportunity to ask clarifying questions regarding the changes made in the articles. For the full articles, see our new Bargaining Portal (here!) which has a tracker for each article, and will also be updated with press releases with quotes and more details.

Our next bargaining session is in three weeks on Thursday, May 1st, 1-4PM. Keep an eye out for details about the caucus room and post-bargaining debriefs. We encourage you to email [email protected], reach us at #ask-bargaining on Slack, or join our WhatsApp group for bargaining announcements if you are interested in learning about or contributing to our contact bargaining process, both at the table and with broader organizing.

  •  

TLDR: Harvard refused to move on open bargaining and denied protections from ICE/DHS for bargaining participants. We will move on by bargaining without ground rules. 

In our second bargaining session with Harvard yesterday (Friday 3/28), we aimed to get movement on two core issues for HGSU members: open bargaining, to ensure negotiations are observable to all members, and enforceable protections against ICE/DHS for anyone who attends sessions.

Despite delivering our petition for open bargaining with over 1200 signatures and direct quotes from student workers and community members, Harvard again rejected all of our proposed ground rules. We have truly tried to compromise towards progress with Harvard on this issue. After Harvard canceled our first bargaining session over concerns that members would attend, we crafted and proposed two new sets of ground rules that clarified norms for observers to assuage Harvard’s fear of “disruption”. Today, we offered them yet another compromise, proposing that bargaining observers would only be present on a muted Zoom webinar. In response to every proposal we made, Harvard refused to meaningfully engage by axing out all of our language around transparent bargaining. In the session yesterday, the University made it clear that they had a problem specifically with “our unit” being able to observe negotiations. Why does Harvard not want HGSU members to see negotiations first hand?

Harvard also refused our request to protect student workers against ICE and other federal agents during bargaining sessions. Given the recent detainments and deportations of student workers at universities across the US and in our community, we asked Harvard to (1) notify HGSU if the University was informed of ICE presence and (2) to enforce key-card access to limit potential ICE entry during bargaining sessions. Harvard not only rejected these two items in ground rules, they also actively refused to even verbally agree with any of these simple actions. When one of our committee members tried to explain the importance of having a safe bargaining room for our bargaining committee, members providing testimonials, and members writ large, the University’s lead negotiator cut them off, saying: “You’ve talked an awful lot.” They directed us to Harvard’s Office for General Counsel guidelines, which don’t provide any material protection against detainment or deportation, and said: “That policy is our policy.” We are appalled by the University’s active negligence and denial of safety during bargaining sessions. Why is Harvard unwilling to do so little as lock a door to make the bargaining room safer for student workers?

Moving forward, we will be bargaining without ground rules until Harvard is willing to meaningfully address our proposals for these key issues of bargaining transparency and safety. We will have updates about what this looks like for you shortly.

TLDR: The University rejected our proposals for open bargaining, safety/accessibility, and reasonable accommodations.

Last Friday, we had our first bargaining session with Harvard. Two weeks after we sent them our proposed ground rules to govern negotiations, the University rejected our proposals, which included a plan for open bargaining (both in-person and on Zoom), and included a request for protections from ICE and other law enforcement agencies during bargaining. They did accept one specific proposed disability accommodation needed for our bargaining committee to fully participate in in-person negotiations.

HGSU members have been collectively advocating for open bargaining, which allows union members to silently observe negotiation sessions that directly impact our rights and working conditions. During our session, the University claimed that the presence of observers would unfairly “pressure them”, and that the open bargaining in 2021 led to a “chilling effect” on some of the Harvard legal team’s members. We took those concerns seriously and asked them repeatedly to clarify them. But they refused to provide details or further negotiate any specific items; they also refused to offer a counterproposal that would meet their needs. Why does Harvard not want HGSU membership to see the bargaining process firsthand?

To address these concerns in good faith, we drafted and sent the University a new counter-proposal within an hour that reiterated the position we held coming into the session, including delineating norms around open and accessible bargaining and demanding protections from law enforcement threats during negotiations.

Our next bargaining session is in 2 weeks — the ball is now in Harvard’s court to articulate what concrete concerns they have about open bargaining.

What’s next? We want Harvard to recognize this demand from HGSU members and community supporters about the need for transparency around our contract bargaining process. We welcome proposals from rank and file members about how we can move the university on open bargaining. We emphasized members wouldn’t be happy to hear that Harvard wants us to compromise on our need for open bargaining – so how should we make that clear to them?

Past Contract Bargaining

 

We present the following HGSU-UAW Local 5118 Initial Bargaining Goals for negotiating our second contract at Harvard.  Our goals draw on extensive feedback, through thousands of conversations and bargaining surveys, coming from a majority of student workers across all segments of the Harvard community. In addition, our goals stem from a year of experience with our first contract and a renewed understanding of the importance of rights, benefits, and protections in our workplace. 

Student workers play an integral role in the quality of Harvard’s core missions of producing cutting-edge research and providing a world-class education to thousands of students each year. Especially in the past year with everyone facing a global pandemic, an economic recession, and fundamental changes to the way research and teaching are conducted at Harvard, the need for protections and rights in the workplace, wherever that may be, has never been clearer. 

In the process of crafting these goals, we had in mind the greater role of graduate student workers and their relationship with Harvard. It is important to emphasize that we are only the second contract campaign in what will be a long future of progressive contracts. We will continue to organize and build power towards improving the lives and workplaces for student workers.

Through these goals, we hope to improve our conditions in ways that enhance our ability to focus on quality teaching and research and also make Harvard a more just and equitable community for all. As a result, our goals for our second contract include:

Equity and Justice: Ensure that all workers can study, work, and live at Harvard without fear of discrimination, harassment, abuse, or retaliation

  • Guarantee that no student worker will be disciplined or retaliated against—in an academic or work context—for filing a complaint about harassment or discrimination;
  • Ensure access to an independent, timely, and fair procedure to address all cases of harassment and discrimination, including identity-based and power-based harassment and discrimination;
  • Provide appointment security and mentorship support for student workers facing concerns with supervisors;
  • Improve access, support, and services for SWs with disabilities.

International Student Worker Protections: Guarantee employment, pay, and visa security

  • Guarantee access to free legal assistance for SWs with visa/immigration issues;
  • Ensure security of pay and benefits for SWs who encounter visa problems or are targeted by discriminatory state or federal policies;
  • Remove or refine the requirement for international SWs to prove financial solvency, especially for G5+ SWs;
  • Improve access to free or no-cost spoken and written English language training.
  • Define international SWs’ visa related subjects/fields individually based on each SW’s concentration;
  • Guarantee SWs are allowed entry to the U.S.

Compensation: Ensure fair compensation for all workers

  • Establish pay and stipend levels for all workers that are in line with the cost of living and with peer institutions;
  • Guarantee annual increases that keep pace with local cost of living;
  • Pay SWs teaching at the School of Public Health the same rates as SWs teaching in GSAS;
  • Ensure timely pay for all SWs;
  • Improve stability of post-5th-year PhD funding, and waive excessive fees for upper-G-year workers;
  • Account for course preparation hours, not just teaching hours, when determining compensation, notably for split fifths.

Healthcare: Improve medical, dental, vision, and mental health care for all SWs

  • Provide medical, dental, and vision insurance for all SWs and their dependents at no cost;
  • Minimize out-of-pocket costs, including prescription costs;
  • Expand the list of covered medications and establish a pharmacy by mail system;
  • Expand provider network including mental health coverage and access to specialists;
  • Lower mental health visit copays;
  • Remove caps on the number of specialist visits allowed.

Working Conditions: Increase security and transparency of all SW positions and enhance access to adequate training for all SWs

  • Ensure Harvard commits to providing equal employment opportunity to its SWs;
  • Provide clear expectations of work responsibilities, hours, and hiring criteria;
  • Ensure full pay or comparable appointment in cases of change or departure of supervisor, course cancellations, or reductions in work for all SWs;
  • Increase SW participation in determining the content of training, particularly to advance initiatives of racial and gender justice in the workplace;
  • Increase opportunities and services for professional and career development; e.g. paid access to conferences, paid time off for job interviews.

Benefits: Establish modern and competitive benefits for all SWs

  • Guarantee fully-paid parental leave, family leave, and medical leave;
  • Ensure that all SWs with children have access to high quality, free or low-cost childcare centers on campus;
  • Provide more flexible access to and waive fees for on-campus childcare centers;
  • Provide year-round MBTA passes at lower or no cost to SWs;
  • Lower costs of university-owned housing for SWs.

Union Recognition and Rights: Establish provisions that enable a strong SW voice through the union

  • Union security through the unit-wide sharing of costs that reflects equal contribution for equal representation;
  • Strengthen union access to facilities, SWs and orientations, office space, and information about the bargaining unit;
  • Provide HGSU-UAW representatives paid release time to provide effective representation to SWs.

Ratified by members in 2018

We present the following HGSU-UAW Initial Bargaining Goals for negotiating our first contract at Harvard.  Our goals draw on extensive feedback, through thousands of conversations and bargaining surveys, coming from a majority of student workers across all segments of the Harvard community. 

Student workers play an integral role in the quality of Harvard’s core missions of producing cutting-edge research and providing a world-class education to thousands of students each year. 

In pursuing these goals, we hope to improve our conditions in ways that enhance our ability to focus on quality teaching and research and also make Harvard a more accessible and inclusive community for all.  Therefore, our demands for our collective bargaining agreement include, but are not limited to, the following goals:

Equity and Inclusivity: Ensure that all Student Workers (SWs) can study, work, and live at Harvard without fear of discrimination, harassment, abuse, or retaliation

  1. Improve inclusion and anti-discrimination and harassment trainings for student workers (SW) and their supervisors.
  2. Improve access, support, and services for SWs with disabilities.
  3. Ensure Harvard demonstrates a strong, ongoing commitment to understanding and addressing the concerns of vulnerable populations on campus.
  4. Establish stronger protections and recourse for sexual and gender-based harassment or assault. Increase protections against profiling and discrimination based on race, color, religion, country of national origin, visa status, sexual orientation, gender identity, age, ability handicap, pregnancy status, or veteran status and other categories.
  5. Improve access, funding, and staffing of centers such as the Women’s Center and the Office of BGLTQ Life and commit to recruiting and appointing underrepresented minorities.
  6. Establish the right to expedited, neutral and procedurally fair, third-party grievance procedure for discrimination, harassment, and other complaints without waiving SW’s rights to other forums.
  7. Guarantee adequate and extensive interim measures and remedies to protect survivors of discrimination, harassment, or assault.
  8. Create paid SWs positions to focus on diversity and inclusion issues.
  9. Ensure that medical confidentiality of SWs is honored.

Compensation: Improve compensation for all SWs

  1. Establish fair pay/stipends for all SWs, including increased minimum pay rates and guaranteed annual increases that keep pace with local cost-of living.
  2. Ensure access to paid SW positions for individuals who want or need them, for example, summer positions and positions for upper-year doctoral students.
  3. Timely compensate SWs for all teaching and research work performed, including but not limited to, substitute teaching, overseeing undergraduate independent studies and out-of-state activities.
  4. Waive tuition and fees for all SWs.
  5. Streamline payroll process, including online time reporting for hourly work.
  6. Establish advance payment for any required, work-related travel and expenses.
  7. Account for course preparation hours, not just teaching hours, when determining compensation, notably for split fifths.

Health Benefits: Improve medical, dental, vision, and mental health care for all SWs

  1. Provide fully-paid medical, dental, and vision insurance for all SWs and their dependents.
  2. Minimize out-of-pocket costs, including prescription costs.
  3. Expand the list of covered medications and establish a pharmacy by mail system.
  4. Expand provider network including mental health coverage and access to specialists.
  5. Increase number of specialist visits allowed.
  6. Ensure access to medical care and prescriptions for traveling and non-local SWs.
  7. Ensure access to providers who are trained and experienced in providing care to individuals with a range of backgrounds, identities, and experiences.
  8. Ensure that University Health Services responds to health and mental health emergencies, without unnecessarily turning to law enforcement.
  9. Eliminate fees related to requests for medical and dental records through HUHS.
  10. Ensure coverage for medication for the special needs of transgender individuals and expand to include procedures not yet covered (e.g. facial surgeries, sperm and egg banking, facial hair removal, vocal coaching, vocal surgeries).

Job Security and Transparency: Increase security and transparency of all SW positions

  1. Ensure that open research and teaching positions are posted publicly and when filling positions, ensure Harvard commits to providing equal employment opportunity to its SWs.
  2. Provide clear expectations of work responsibilities, hours, and hiring criteria.
  3. Notify SWs about job appointments in a timely manner.
  4. Ensure full pay or comparable appointment in cases of change or departure of supervisor, course cancellations, or reductions in work.
  5. Protect SWs from discipline and/or discharge without just cause

 International Student Worker Protections: Ensure that all SWs study, work, and live at Harvard without fear of deportation, retaliation, or discrimination

  1. Guarantee access to free legal assistance for SWs with visa/immigration issues.
  2. Ensure security of pay and benefits for SWs who encounter visa problems or are targeted by discriminatory state or federal policies.
  3. Remove or refine the requirement for international SWs to prove financial solvency.
  4. Improve access to free or no-cost spoken and written English language training.
  5. Define international SWs’ visa related subjects/fields individually based on each SW’s concentration.

 Leaves of Absence: Establish fully-paid leave policies for all SWs

  1. Guarantee fully-paid sick leave, parental leave (for childbirth, fostering, and adoption), family leave, and leave for bereavement, jury duty, and military duty.
  2. Ensure workers’ compensation for SWs who are injured on the job.
  3. Provide health insurance during leaves of absence at no additional cost.
  4. Ensure access to minimum paid vacation time off (time to visit family, travel, etc.).
  5. Provide protections for SWs who take leave at critical academic times.
  6. Ensure that SWs maintain access to university-owned housing while on leave.

Childcare: Improve childcare and dependent benefits for all SWs

  1. Ensure that all SWs with children have access to high quality, free or low-cost childcare centers on campus.
  2. Provide more flexible access to on-campus childcare centers.
  3. Waive application fees for on-campus childcare.
  4. Ensure convenient access to safe, private lactation stations.
  5. Expand access to existing childcare programs that currently cover other university affiliates.
  6. Provide childcare subsidies for off-campus childcare centers.

Transportation: Improve transportation services for all SWs and their dependents

  1. Provide year-round MBTA passes.
  2. Establish a bicycle reimbursement program to aid ownership and maintenance.
  3. Extend and expand shuttle services.
  4. Establish institutional discounts for rideshares for use as emergency rides.
  5. Provide Parking and Park-and-ride benefits.

Housing: Enhance access to affordable housing for all SWs

  1. Lower costs of university-owned housing for SWs.
  2. Expand access to university-owned housing for all SWs, including those with dependents.
  3. Establish that no SWs can be required to pay rent in university-owned housing until SW receives their pay.
  4. Ensure that graduate SWs living in university-owned housing can pay rent and meal plans monthly (rather than by semester or year) without additional fees.

 Training & Professional Development: Enhance access to adequate training for all SWs

  1. Guarantee pay for all required training and orientations.
  2. Ensure the availability of training necessary to fulfill job responsibilities.
  3. Increase SW participation in determining the content of training.           
  4. Increase opportunities and services for professional and career development; e.g. paid access to conferences, University courses, and other classes; paid time off for job interviews; and improved mentorship.
  5. Ensure equal access to necessary academic software across Harvard’s campuses.

Healthy Work Environment: Ensure that all SWs work in a healthy, safe, non-abusive environment

  1. Ensure a healthy and safe work environment.
  2. Improve intellectual property rights for all SWs, including but not limited to, patents, authorship, and copyright protections.
  3. Ensure access to a workspace and adequate equipment and resources for all SWs, including emergency and non-emergency research needs (e.g. data access fees).
  4. Establish fair and reasonable workload protections.
  5. Provide personal space convenient to the workplace (e.g., places to take private phone calls, space to store belongings).

Financial Stability Protections: Relieve the financial burdens on SWs

  1. Improve and expand needs-based financial aid programs.
  2. Improve and expand loan repayment assistance programs.
  3. Establish a retirement benefit system for SWs.
  4. Establish emergency grant funds (e.g. costs associated with medical, family, immigration-related emergencies).
  5. Provide tax preparation advice and resources (e.g. reimbursement for professional tax preparation services or software).

Union Recognition and Rights: Establish provisions that enable a strong SW voice through the union

  1. Affirm that Harvard recognizes HGSU-UAW as the exclusive bargaining representative for SWs in the bargaining unit.    
  2. Allow Union access to facilities, SWs and orientations, office space, and information about the bargaining unit.
  3. Provide HGSU-UAW representatives paid release time to provide effective representation to SWs.
  4. Ensure that individuals doing bargaining unit work are covered by and have all rights under the contract.
  5. Ensure levels of SW positions that promote excellence in teaching and research.
  6. Ensure that all SWs receive adequate information about their Union, their collective bargaining agreement, and rights including access to grievance procedures.
  7. Establish a fair grievance procedure with the option of neutral arbitration.
  8. Establish clauses on union security and dues deduction, severability, successorship and duration of the contract.

If you have any questions, or would like to contribute to / provide testimonial for any articles, you can reach us at [email protected] !